The Sea Ranch “Utopian” Narrative

Before 2019, the articles describing Sea Ranch included a range of topics: landscape architecture, architectural design, Sea Ranch “ideas,” and Sea Ranch “celebrity” architects.

2019 articles are self-referential and all emphasize architectural design and individual architects in order to establish a legacy narrative. Each article also draws on Sea Ranch “ideals,” but only as inference. No 2019 Sea Ranch article narrates beyond architecture. Landscape management practices that enable humans to “Live Lightly on the Land” in Sea Ranch have been abandoned, while the “utopian” narrative distracts from the need for a functional, sustainable landscape management policy.

The Sea Ranch “utopian” narrative also includes its justification for destruction of habitat. As reported in the New York Times, Lisa Dundee, an architect and longtime director of the Sea Ranch Association’s powerful Department of Design, Compliance and Environmental Management, demonstrates how fear is driving TSRA landscape policies: “With Northern California — well, actually all of California — burning up, we’ve really had to challenge ourselves to find alternatives to our traditions.” (Ms. Dundee flashed a picture of a fire in Napa on her screen to the journalist while asserting, in Sea Ranch, that the whole state is on fire.) The “fear of fire” narrative trickles down from Dundee-TSRA, infecting other residents, and leaving the path clear to cut.

The preservationist tradition–“Living Lightly on the Land”–is the tradition being annihilated alongside the other animals’ habitats. The Center’s documentation demonstrates that the majority of cutting decisions are for human architectural enhancement and views, not fire safety. Dundee-TSRA appear to use fire safety as a cover for unprecedented cutting and clearing in 2019.

The lack of any policy at the Sea Ranch devoted to protecting nonhuman animals and other beings (including monarch butterflies) leaves in place the current and on-going unnecessary destruction of nonhuman habitat. Without devoted attention, human architecture will always trump other animals’ homes here, even if the humans only visit occasionally forcing all the other animals to adapt constantly to the human-controlled environment.

THE SEA RANCH “UTOPIAN” NARRATIVE

2019- Sea Ranch narrative sales pieces:

Sea Ranch Architecture gets an upgrade–no section or discussion of current land or landscape management practices: https://www.pressdemocrat.com/lifestyle/9697675-181/sonoma-countys-sea-ranch-hailed?sba=AAS

Sea Ranch Legacy, Utopia, Architecture–no section or discussion of current land or landscape management practices: https://www.dwell.com/article/sea-ranch-architecture-7f30ea15

Sea Ranch Modernist Utopia, Architecture–no section or discussion of current land or landscape management practices: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/11/arts/design/sea-ranch-california.html

SFMOMA promo piece–mentions “Environment” in the title, but no section or discussion of current land or landscape management practices: https://www.sfmoma.org/press/release/the-sea-ranch/

Dezeen SFMOMA piece (scroll down to find Eleanor Gibson’s piece). Although the words “environment” and “landscape” appear in the article, no description or discussion of current landscape practices is offered.

Curbed Sea Ranch Oral History, Pt. 1 piece quotes Larry Halprin within a “utopian” narrative history, thereby effectively characterizing his “Live Lightly on the Land” ethic as currently “naive.” No mention of current TSRA landscape management policies or practices in this carefully crafted “complete” history. https://www.curbed.com/2019/2/20/18231590/sea-ranch-northern-california-sonoma-county-coast-history

Curbed Sea Ranch Oral History, Pt. 2 piece quotes Mary Griffin and Lisa Dundee grappling with how to save the human architecture from fire. Missing is any discussion or consideration of a sustainable landscape policy that protects both human and nonhuman habitat in this carefully crafted “complete” history. https://www.curbed.com/2019/2/21/18232116/sea-ranch-coastal-commission-oral-history-legacy

Sea Ranch VIP sales narrative (PDF): http://www.tsra.org/photos/VIPBooklet.pdf

The Sea Ranch Association website narrative–landscape management declared and inferred as “Live Lightly on the Land”: https://www.tsra.org/news.php?viewStory=1790

As The Sea Ranch wiki narrates it, no landscape policies exist beyond no non-native plants and no planting outside fenced courtyards. An incomplete description of grasses management only mentions sheep. Sea Ranch “owners” are free to cut and spray as they see fit. “Larry Halprin” listed under landscape–no further information is provided. (Hard, non-democratic firewall patrolled by Dundee-TSRA. Even with citations and documentation, attempts to add to an incomplete Wiki account–from a current resident of Sea Ranch–was declared “malicious.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_Ranch,_California

Pre-2019 narrative

Utopia Rules at Sea Ranch, NYT 2015: One journalist’s experience at the Lodge. No mention of landscape architectural practices

Landscape Architecture Magazine piece that only quotes TSRA literature without any focus, description, or mention of actual landscape architecture or management policies or practices.

Ostensibly about landscape architecture and design, the blog post mentions nothing about those actual policies or practices; simply invokes Halprin.

Curbed article about specific Sea Ranch house. No utopia narrative; no mention of landscape management policies or practices. https://www.curbed.com/2018/4/9/17192240/sea-ranch-california-home-tour-framestudio

All of The Sea Ranch Association rules. All related to architecture, building, maintenance. etc. No articulation of a functional, sustainable landscape management policy or practice. http://www.tsra.org/photos/TSRA_Rules.pdf